Hydroviv and Clearly Filtered offer under-sink and fridge filters that share similarities, such as utilizing carbon filtration and official certifications, but they differ in crucial aspects.
Hydroviv stands out for its NSF-certified customized filters tailored to your location, although it removes fewer contaminants.
On the other hand, Clearly Filtered boasts a broader contaminant removal, being tested against NSF standards by WQA.
Continue reading for a detailed comparison to determine which is worth your money.
👉Hydroviv Filter: Pros and Cons
Pros
- Customized filtration based on locality
- 99% contaminant removal rate for 20+ contaminants
- Independently tested for effectiveness
- Better-tasting water
- Compact design
- Easy installation and filter replacement
- 30-day money-back guarantee
- 1-year limited warranty against defects
Cons
- It does not remove bacteria, fluoride, nitrates
- Lack of transparency about filter material used.
👉Clearly Filtered: Pros and Cons
Pros
- Removes 230+ contaminants with independent testing
- High filtration capacity
- Easy installation process
- Quick filter cartridge replacement
- Low maintenance cost
- Lifetime warranty
Cons
- Bit more expensive than other under-sink filters
- Less personalized experience compared to custom filters
- Costly replacement filters
Here's How We Test Products At Aquaprofessor
👉Which Under-Sink Is Better: Hydroviv or Clearly Filtered?
| Basis | Hydroviv Under-Sink | Clearly Filtered Under-Sink |
| Contaminant Removal | 99% removal of 20+ impurities such as PFAS, Lead, Arsenic, Chromium 6, Hydrogen sulfide, VOCs, pesticides | 99.9% removal of 230+ impurities such as arsenic, disinfection byproducts, VOCs, and more |
| Performance Certifications | Independently tested for NSF 42 and 53 standards | Certified by WQA against NSF/ANSI standards, including NSF 42, 53, 372, and 401. |
| Filtration Capacity and Water Flow Rate | 720 Gallons of water 2 GPM (Gallons Per Minute) | 2,000 Gallons of water |
| Ease of Installation | Easy | Easy |
| Ease of Maintenance | Filter replacement is required twice a year | Filter replacement is required once a year |
| Warranty and Customer Support | Good customer support 1-year limited warranty | Satisfactory customer support Lifetime warranty |
| Price | Check Price | Check Price |
🦠Contaminant Removal
Hydroviv‘s under-sink water filtration system utilizes advanced activated carbon block technology with an impressive 99% removal rate.
It eliminates 20+ common water contaminants, such as chlorine, lead, PFAS, arsenic, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), while retaining healthy minerals.
Their tailored approach to water filtration studies Water Quality Reports to know water impurities specific to your area and supply customized filters (however, the reliability of this process is doubtful).
However, remember that Hydroviv does not eliminate fluoride, bacteria, or nitrates.
Clearly Filtered under-sink water filter systems excel in removing more than 232 contaminants, making them an excellent choice for households water quality concerns.
With a dedicated filter stage for arsenic removal and an impressive 94.3% reduction rate, Clearly Filtered ensures your water is free from harmful impurities.
Winner: Clearly Filtered is a clear winner because its ability to remove over 232 contaminants, including arsenic, with a dedicated filter stage, gives it the edge in this category.
🏅Performance Certifications
Hydroviv filters are independently tested for NSF/ANSI standards 42 and 53 to prove their contaminant removal capabilities.
On the other hand, Clearly Filtered is backed by NSF 42, 53, and 401 certifications after rigorous testing by WQA to prove its efficiency in removing arsenic and other contaminants.
The official certifications provide peace of mind to consumers, knowing they can rely on the filter’s performance to deliver clean, safe drinking water.
Winner: Clearly Filtered is the winner here as it has the original NSF certifications for reducing more contaminants commonly found in tap water.
💦Filtration Capacity and Water Flow Rate
Hydroviv‘s under-sink system has a filtration capacity of approximately 720 gallons or six months for typical household use, ensuring reliable filtration performance.
The water flow rate is 2 gallons per minute or 500 gallons per day under 60 psi pressure, catering to most household needs without compromising efficiency.
Clearly Filtered under-sink filters offer a filtration capacity of 2000 gallons, offering long-lasting performance equivalent to approximately 15 months of typical use.
Despite its thorough filtration process, the system maintains a respectable water flow rate, ensuring a continuous clean water supply without compromising efficiency.
Winner: Clearly Filtered is the winner because of its high filtration capacity and good water flow rate.
🔧Ease of Installation
Installing a Hydroviv under-sink water filter is easy, thanks to its installation guide and user-friendly design.
While the package does not include its own faucet, connecting it to your existing faucet is easy. You can also opt for a separate faucet installation for filtered water.
Installing a Clearly Filtered under-sink water filter is hassle-free with its user-friendly design and easy set-up.
Winner: It’s a Tie as both Hydroviv and Clearly Filtered offer user-friendly installation processes, making it easy for homeowners to set up their under-sink water filters without hassle.
🏆Ease of Maintenance
Maintaining your Hydroviv filter is simple and budget-friendly.
The periodic filter replacements are typically required every six months for optimal performance.
You can only purchase these customized replacement filters from Hydroviv, rather than going for other OEM or aftermarket filters.
Maintaining your Clearly Filtered is easy as filter replacements are required once a year, lasting longer than hydroviv.
Note that while Clearly Filtered requires less frequent replacements than Hydroviv, its filters will cost you more.
Winner: Hydroviv is the winner here because of its economical and easy maintenance.
👷♂️Warranty and Customer Support
Hydroviv offers a 30-day money-back guarantee, ensuring a risk-free purchase experience.
Additionally, the product is backed by a one-year limited manufacturer’s warranty, although some customers have reported challenges with warranty claims.
Besides, you can contact their customer support team via email, live chat facility during business hours, or snail mail.
Clearly Filtered also offers peace of mind to its customers with a limited lifetime warranty.
It has responsive customer support to address customer concerns via live chat facility, call, SMS service, or email form.
Winner: It’s a Tie as both offer satisfactory customer support to their customers.
🏆Which Fridge Filter Is Better: Hydroviv or Clearly Filtered?
| Basis | Hydroviv Ice Maker Water Filter | Clearly Filtered Universal Inline Water Filter |
| Contaminant Removal | Removes 20+ contaminants | Removes 230+ contaminants |
| Performance Certifications | NSF 42 and 53 | NSF 42, 53, and 401 |
| Filtration Capacity and Water Flow Rate | 720 gallons | 365 Gallons |
| Compatibility | It can be installed behind any fridge | It can be installed behind any fridge |
| Ease of Installation | Easy | Easy |
| Ease of Maintenance | Needs replacement every 9 months | Needs replacement every 12 months |
| Warranty and Customer Support | 1-year limited warranty against defects. Good customer support | Lifetime Warranty Satisfactory customer support |
| Price | Check Price | Check Price |
🦠Contaminant Removal
Hydroviv’s Ice Maker Water Filter is designed to remove 20+ contaminants, addressing common impurities such as chlorine, lead, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs).
Clearly Filtered Universal Inline Water Filter excels in contaminant removal, eliminating over 230 harmful contaminants.
Its three-stage filtration process removes a wide range of impurities, including heavy metals, fluoride, and arsenic.
Winner: Clearly Filtered is the winner because of its high contaminant removal rate.
🏅Performance Certifications
Hydroviv Ice Maker Water Filter is independently tested for NSF 42 and 53 standards, assuring its performance in reducing chlorine, lead, and other contaminants commonly found in water.
Clearly Filtered refrigerator inline filter holds NSF 42, 53, and 401 certifications, validating its efficiency in removing contaminants, including arsenic, chlorine, disinfection byproducts, and pharmaceuticals.
Winner: Clearly Filtered is the winner for its official certifications and high contaminant removal from dirty tap water to improve water taste.
💦Filtration Capacity and Water Flow Rate
Hydroviv refrigerator filter has a filtration capacity of 720 gallons, offering reliable performance for approximately nine months.
Its good water flow rate ensures a consistent water supply without compromising efficiency.
Clearly Filtered inline water filter has a filtration capacity of 365 gallons, providing clean drinking water for up to 12 months.
As per users, it maintains an adequate water flow rate despite a potentially slower water pressure.
Winner: Hydroviv is a winner here because of its high water filtration capacity and decent flow rate.
🔧Ease of Installation
Hydroviv ice maker water filter is praiseworthy for its ease of installation, making it a straightforward process for homeowners to set up behind any refrigerator.
Clearly Filtered universal inline water filter also offers easy installation, requiring no specialized tools, and its inline design is compatible with any fridge.
Winner: It’s a Tie as both filters offer user-friendly installation processes.
👷♂️Ease of Maintenance
Hydroviv ice maker water filter requires replacement every nine months, ensuring continued optimal performance.
However, some customers may find the replacement interval relatively frequent depending on their water needs.
Clearly Filtered universal inline water filter requires replacement every 12 months, offering longer intervals between maintenance.
Both filters can be replaced easily by following the user manual.
Winner: Clearly Filtered is the winner for its longer replacement interval and, thus, lower maintenance costs.
🛃Warranty and Customer Support
The Hydroviv refrigerator filter is backed by a one-year limited warranty against defects.
It provides decent customer support to address customer issues via email, live chat facility during business hours, or snail main.
Clearly Filtered inline water filter offers a lifetime warranty, ensuring long-term customer protection.
It also offers responsive customer support via live chat facility, call, SMS service, or email form to address customer concerns.
Winner: Clearly Filtered is the winner here for its lifetime warranty, providing superior long-term coverage and additional customer support benefits.
🏆Final Takeaway: Who is the Ultimate Winner?
After thorough analysis and comparison of various factors, we declare a tie between Clearly Filtered and Hydroviv under-sink and fridge filters.
Clearly Filtered is a good choice if you are looking for comprehensive filtration.
Whereas, for a budget-friendly purchase, Hydroviv can be a great fit for your household.
💡Hydroviv VS Clearly Filtered: FAQs
Does Hydroviv really remove PFAS?
Yes, Hydroviv’s filtration system effectively removes PFAS (perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances) and other common city water contaminants like lead, chlorine, and VOCs.
It has a high contaminant removal rate compared to Brita or Aquasana.
What does Clearly Filtered filter out?
Clearly Filtered under-sink water filters are designed to remove over 232 contaminants, including heavy metals, VOCs, chlorine, chloramines, fluoride, chromium-6, lead, pesticides, pharmaceuticals, and other chemicals.
Is Hydroviv better than reverse osmosis filters?
It depends on your specific needs and preferences.
Hydroviv’s filtration system does not waste water and uses advanced activated carbon filters to remove contaminants in your local water quality and retain beneficial minerals.
While reverse osmosis (RO) systems waste water (2:1 pure-to-drain ratio), but are highly effective at removing a wide range of contaminants, including bacteria and nitrates, that Hydroviv cannot.
Is Clearly filtered NSF-certified?
Yes, Clearly Filtered undergoes rigorous testing by WQA and holds NSF certifications for standards 43, 53, and 401.
These certifications validate its efficiency in removing contaminants, such as arsenic, chlorine, lead, and VOCs, ensuring clean and safe water for consumers.
Which is more cost-effective, Hydroviv or Clearly Filtered?
The cost-effectiveness of a water filter depends on various factors, including initial cost, maintenance expenses, filter life, and water usage.
Hydroviv has a high initial cost and expensive customized replacement filters.
Whereas, Clearly Filtered offers a longer filter lifespan and less frequent filter replacements, reducing long-term maintenance costs.
So, Clearly Filtered is more cost-effective for an average household.
Adarsh is a Health & Nutrition Sciences graduate with expertise in environmental health. He is associated with ventures like Glacier Fresh Filter and Simpure Filter Systems. Through Aqua Professor, he intends to provide helpful information to every home to help them make smarter decisions.
